Hi guys,
So I talked to a doctor and he's able to secure my surgery for free with my current insurance. Now, he told me he's done 50 - 60 implants a year; and has been doing implants for the past 8 years. I asked him how much does he charge for surgery and he said $37k. He said that it takes a month and a half to recover from postop surgery.
My previous doctor who's a high volume surgeon recommended him. That previous doctor is moving to another clinic and can't perform surgery on me, sadly. Thats why he recommended this doctor. 
I can afford to pay $30k out of pocket for surgery elsewhere, but its still very expensive. And as I said, this surgery is free with my insurance. So do you think this doctor is good enough to perform surgery?
.
			
									
									
						Is this doctor good enough for implant surgery?
- 
				macoza
- Posts: 234
- Joined: Sat Oct 15, 2022 7:45 pm
- 
				Valdekio
- Posts: 52
- Joined: Wed Sep 10, 2025 8:47 pm
Re: Is this doctor good enough for implant surgery?
What is his name?macoza wrote:Hi guys,
So I talked to a doctor and he's able to secure my surgery for free with my current insurance. Now, he told me he's done 50 - 60 implants a year; and has been doing implants for the past 8 years. I asked him how much does he charge for surgery and he said $37k. He said that it takes a month and a half to recover from postop surgery.
My previous doctor who's a high volume surgeon recommended him. That previous doctor is moving to another clinic and can't perform surgery on me, sadly. Thats why he recommended this doctor.
I can afford to pay $30k out of pocket for surgery elsewhere, but its still very expensive. And as I said, this surgery is free with my insurance. So do you think this doctor is good enough to perform surgery?
.
59 yr old. Implanted Sept.19, 2025
AMS 700 CX 18 cm + 1.50 extenders
Married 22 years to the love of my life.
Struggled with ED for the last 20 years.
Meds, pumps, injections quit working.
						AMS 700 CX 18 cm + 1.50 extenders
Married 22 years to the love of my life.
Struggled with ED for the last 20 years.
Meds, pumps, injections quit working.
- 
				lasthope2.0
- Posts: 24
- Joined: Sat Oct 11, 2025 1:23 pm
Re: Is this doctor good enough for implant surgery?
I would also contact the insurance company to check if these CPT codes are covered by your plan. 
54405 (inflatable)
54400 (semirigid)
(CPT - Current Procedural Terminology)
If they are, any high-volume in-network surgeon should get you covered. Insurance billing is done using CPT codes, regardless of which in-network surgeon you choose.
			
									
									
						54405 (inflatable)
54400 (semirigid)
(CPT - Current Procedural Terminology)
If they are, any high-volume in-network surgeon should get you covered. Insurance billing is done using CPT codes, regardless of which in-network surgeon you choose.
- 
				Ephi82
- Posts: 114
- Joined: Wed Apr 02, 2025 8:39 am
Re: Is this doctor good enough for implant surgery?
He’s not what I consider high volume, but he’s been doing them for eight years, so he has a lot of experience.  If he has a good reputation overall, I would go with him if he’s your only choice in terms of insurance coverage.
			
									
									66 years old.  Long term progressive ED.  Pills and injections no longer the solution. 
Implanted 4/4/2025. AMS 700CX 21cm with .5 extenders
						Implanted 4/4/2025. AMS 700CX 21cm with .5 extenders
- 
				Asdefxx
- Posts: 14
- Joined: Mon Aug 19, 2024 12:17 pm
Re: Is this doctor good enough for implant surgery?
lasthope2.0 wrote:I would also contact the insurance company to check if these CPT codes are covered by your plan.
54405 (inflatable)
54400 (semirigid)
(CPT - Current Procedural Terminology)
If they are, any high-volume in-network surgeon should get you covered. Insurance billing is done using CPT codes, regardless of which in-network surgeon you choose.
Sorry, can you elaborate on this? Do I literally just call up my insurance company and ask "hey may I ask if CPTs 54400 and 54405 are covered under my plan?"
- 
				Bandit
- Posts: 420
- Joined: Sat May 13, 2017 7:27 am
- Location: Rhode Island
Re: Is this doctor good enough for implant surgery?
Why get “good enough”. Put it off. Save some money and do it right. If you go ahead and get it done “good enough” and your not satisfied you will not forgive yourself. Do research. Go high volume. Its your dick. Don’t settle for less than !!!
Bandit
			
									
									Bandit
Born 1958, married. Prostate Cancer. RRP November/2014. PSA undetectable since.  Implant May/2017 AMS700LGX 18 cm + 1.5 cm RTEs. 8 years and implant developed a leak. Revision by Dr Eid 6/27/25. Coloplast Titan 20 cm.
						- 
				lasthope2.0
- Posts: 24
- Joined: Sat Oct 11, 2025 1:23 pm
Re: Is this doctor good enough for implant surgery?
Asdefxx wrote:lasthope2.0 wrote:I would also contact the insurance company to check if these CPT codes are covered by your plan.
54405 (inflatable)
54400 (semirigid)
(CPT - Current Procedural Terminology)
If they are, any high-volume in-network surgeon should get you covered. Insurance billing is done using CPT codes, regardless of which in-network surgeon you choose.
Sorry, can you elaborate on this? Do I literally just call up my insurance company and ask "hey may I ask if CPTs 54400 and 54405 are covered under my plan?"
Asdefxx, yes.
I have annual enrollment this week for 2026. I contacted the three plans offered at work, asked about these CPT codes, and enrolled in the one that said, ‘You’re covered with a $2,000 copay,’ without the complicated medical-necessity caveats. (Goodbye, to my old Aetna plan.). Of course, things can get highly subjective to an employer's specific commercial plan.
- 
				JohnHC
- Posts: 324
- Joined: Mon Apr 24, 2023 9:35 am
Re: Is this doctor good enough for implant surgery?
I would say if a well known high volume Dr suggested or referred him to you, it's a safe bet that he should be ok to use otherwise your Dr would not have recommended him.
			
									
									AMS 700 CX 21 cm X 12 mm with 2 cm rear tip extenders. Tenacio pump and 100 ml conceal reservoir done by Dr Hakky on Feb 18th 2025
						- 
				Gt1956
- Posts: 3239
- Joined: Fri Apr 05, 2019 2:47 pm
Re: Is this doctor good enough for implant surgery?
Personally I'm cautious of friend referrals. You never know if he is a "friend" from golfing or church.
That aside. Be carefull. Even though my insurance covered my surgery. There was a $1500 copay to the hospital. Plus the anesthesiologist didn't do insurance billing. I had to pay the fee then fight it out with the insurance company. That was an almost $3000 I had to deal with. Just saying its covered doesn't mean its ALL covered.
The fact that you have not mentioned the drs name is an even bigger red flag to me.
Drs pay for malpractice insurance based on the number of related surgeries in a category. In the implant category there are other procedures included. Him saying he does 40 implants a year could be him quoting how many related surgeries he is paying insurance on. For example, if it was 1 implant & 39 baby circumcisions would he look as competent to you. Or 2 implants & 38 bladder repairs on old women?
Be very careful about numbers that are thrown around casually. It is your only dick. Ask detailed questions. English can be spoken in a twisted manner.
I guess my point is that YOU have to be your own advocate. Words don't always mean what you think they do.
Best of luck to you.
			
									
									That aside. Be carefull. Even though my insurance covered my surgery. There was a $1500 copay to the hospital. Plus the anesthesiologist didn't do insurance billing. I had to pay the fee then fight it out with the insurance company. That was an almost $3000 I had to deal with. Just saying its covered doesn't mean its ALL covered.
The fact that you have not mentioned the drs name is an even bigger red flag to me.
Drs pay for malpractice insurance based on the number of related surgeries in a category. In the implant category there are other procedures included. Him saying he does 40 implants a year could be him quoting how many related surgeries he is paying insurance on. For example, if it was 1 implant & 39 baby circumcisions would he look as competent to you. Or 2 implants & 38 bladder repairs on old women?
Be very careful about numbers that are thrown around casually. It is your only dick. Ask detailed questions. English can be spoken in a twisted manner.
I guess my point is that YOU have to be your own advocate. Words don't always mean what you think they do.
Best of luck to you.
69yo, HBP @ 40, high triglycerides @ 45. Phimosis @ 57. Type 2 @ 60. Dr. William Brant May 1, 2023 CX 21cm w/no rte's penoscrotal 6" girth @ 6 months.
						Who is online
Users browsing this forum: GPTBot and 34 guests
 
						 
						 
						 
						 
						 
						