Lawrence,
1. Hang in there. 3 weeks post op is embryonic in terms of recovery. You are having a
"WTF have I done?" experience, and questioning everything, despite having done all the due diligence beforehand, which likely indicated an implant to be the best option before you committed to it. Many of us have had similar experiences. At 3 weeks I still had to put up with a 30% to 40% erection 24/7, which was also nearly 2 inches shorter than my pre ED length. It caused all kinds of problems taking a piss, and I wasn't even allowed to use it for sex until after 6 weeks! And it was 9 months before I could confidently confirm that I had recovered pre ED length and girth.
2. While it's true that ED and implants tend to be biased towards middle age or older guys, there are quite a few younger men on here with with implants or researching them. There is currently some interesting discussion between 1984ptc and splitpeach about their recoveries. Both also recently implanted, of similar age, evaluating their progress and expectations vs results so far. It might be worth reading for comparison.
https://www.franktalk.org/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=6&t=27925#p2696593. Cycling isn't a magic bullet that will instantly restore what you had before. In my experience it does help but takes time and patience.
Regardless of age everyone's recovery timeframe is different and it can vary wildly. You had a more complex procedure than most. It could be that the additional trauma means your corporeal tissue may take longer to fully heal and adapt to the implant cylinders to restore your size.
4. You were implanted by one of the world's leading surgeons. Trust in his ability to get the outcome you desire, over time.
5. Yes it can feel unnatural for quite a while. I would say mine only felt 100% comfortable and natural once I could have sex totally pain free, many months down the track. Once that happened my sexual confidence went through the roof. Now I can't wait for the next opportunity to pump it up and fuck for as long as possible, without ever losing my erection. It has never felt better or more natural, even in my twenties it wasn't this good.
6. Even the MS pump on my LGX makes a very slight wheezing sound, but only on deflation. I'm the only one who can hear it and only when it's very quiet. Otherwise ambient noise completely masks it. Like others have said there are many ways to pump discreetly if you think the sound will be a problem.
7. Try and focus on the positives. No pain or meds, you can orgasm already, and can conceal your flaccid. Like many I couldn't do any of those things at 3 weeks. I wasn't even allowed to deflate my dick to flaccid for 6 weeks, so concealing it was very challenging. Discomfort persisted for months. I had numbness underneath the shaft. It was probably 3 months after I started having sex again before I could orgasm consistently. None of these things is uncommon but recovery protocols and experience can differ greatly.
Finally, we hear you and understand your frustration. Appreciate your honesty, but probably not the best idea to use inflammatory comments that tend to alienate people. Most of us have no medical training. Just a bunch of guys trying to fix the same problem and offer whatever support and reassurance that we can for fellow sufferers.
71, married, Sydney Oz. PC/nerve sparing RRP Mar 2022 caused 100% total ED. Tried pills, Trimix inj, focal shockwave, VED. All failed. Implanted Mar 6 2025 AMS 700 LGX 21cm x 12mm, no RTEs, MS pump, Penoscrotal. Got back to 6.5" BPEL @ 9m. Loving it.