To implant or not. Opinions needed

The final frontier. Deciding when, if and how.
Gumby1
Posts: 3
Joined: Mon Dec 30, 2024 6:59 pm

To implant or not. Opinions needed

Postby Gumby1 » Mon Jan 26, 2026 6:14 pm

Gentlemen, I’ve been seriously considering getting an implant. A bit of background on where I’m at currently.
I cannot get a normal or even close to normal erections for a few decades now. Always had issues getting and maintaining erections even as a young man. I started using pills like viagra and cialis, the latter being the best for me but it still wasn’t 100% effective. About 15 years ago, I started using injections and it works very well, especially when combined with Cialis. I finally had good hard erections that lasted and also contributed significantly to longer endurance even after climax. I’m still working well with this combination but I’m afraid I may reach a point when it may stop working. The debacle I’m having is whether or not I should get an implant since I’m still doing well. The other reason I bring this up is that I’m almost 60 years old. I’m still in decent shape/health. My concern is if it stops working and I’m now approaching say 65-70, is that going to impact my ability to even get the surgery ? The other issue I have is the lack of spontaneity, always having to say, “I’ll be right back” in the middle of foreplay. Then there’s traveling for vacation and having to pack the injections with ice which so far, I’m fortunate that I haven’t been questioned by TSA which would be hard to explain.
Soooo… do I wait or do I pull the trigger pre-emptively ?

Handyman
Posts: 72
Joined: Sat Apr 26, 2025 9:08 am

Re: To implant or not. Opinions needed

Postby Handyman » Mon Jan 26, 2026 7:38 pm

Check my posts. I hated the shots and the pain and lack of success. Super happy with implant. You think you can continue to go for round 2 with shot, an implant will let you control that better (aka as long as you like) good luck in your decision making process. For me it came down to frustration about spontanaity (lack of) , pain (lots of) and inconsistent results.
Believe post prostate surgery I was around 5 inches down from 6. Never measured girth but post titan otr 20 cm seems thicker.
Implant by Dr. Stuart Schoengold

LGXDownunder
Posts: 638
Joined: Fri Mar 07, 2025 7:59 am
Location: Sydney, Australia

Re: To implant or not. Opinions needed

Postby LGXDownunder » Tue Jan 27, 2026 12:15 am

My implant was done in March last year at age 70. I've had a few medical issues the past few years, significantly prostate cancer/RRP causing my ED, and a knee replacement. But otherwise I'm still in reasonable shape, active and fitter than most of my peers. So in theory you probably still have time.
Personally I struggled to last 3 years with profound ED before finally committing to an implant. Injections only worked briefly and caused more problems than they solved. Pills were completely useless. So my only partial remedy was using a VED, which was less than satisfactory but better than nothing.
I also hated all of the rigmarole with injections and it was always a gamble whether I would actually get an erection.
It really depends on how you perceive your current quality of (sex) life vs what it might be like with an implant.
For me the decision to get an implant was a no brainer, but it sounds like you have more time to consider it and do the research thoroughly.
71, married, Sydney Oz. PC/nerve sparing RRP Mar 22 then profound ED. Tried pills, Trimix inj, focal shockwave, VED.
Implanted Mar 6 2025 AMS 700 LGX 21cm x 12mm, no RTEs, MS pump, Penoscrotal. Back to 6.5" BPEL @ 9m.
Recovery great but have a bend.

Oz1958
Posts: 24
Joined: Sun Mar 16, 2025 11:17 pm
Location: Adelaide, Australia

Re: To implant or not. Opinions needed

Postby Oz1958 » Tue Jan 27, 2026 3:56 am

My concern is if it stops working and I’m now approaching say 65-70, is that going to impact my ability to even get the surgery ?


My experience is that this is the preferred age for implant. First question implanters I consulted asked was " how old are you?" Statisticly by that age the chances of the implant outliving you are much higher. For younger men the need for one or more revisions is almost certain.
ED since my 40s, managed by pills.
Increasingly severe BPH, emergency HoLEP prostatectomy Nov 2021.
Fixed the prostate but pills slowly became less and less effective.
AMS 700 CX 20th Jan 2026

Gumby1
Posts: 3
Joined: Mon Dec 30, 2024 6:59 pm

Re: To implant or not. Opinions needed

Postby Gumby1 » Tue Jan 27, 2026 6:28 am

Handyman wrote:For me it came down to frustration about spontanaity (lack of)

This is one of my major reasons. I’ll definitely check out your posts.

Gumby1
Posts: 3
Joined: Mon Dec 30, 2024 6:59 pm

Re: To implant or not. Opinions needed

Postby Gumby1 » Tue Jan 27, 2026 7:21 am

LGXDownunder wrote:Pills were completely useless.
I also hated all of the rigmarole with injections

I pretty much feel the same way. You do bring up a good point, I guess I do still have some time to decide. Regardless, I was thinking about waiting until the FDA here in the US approves the Rigicom Infla10 AX which will hopefully be later this year.

Old Guy
Posts: 3021
Joined: Tue Mar 31, 2020 4:31 pm
Location: Ohio

Re: To implant or not. Opinions needed

Postby Old Guy » Tue Jan 27, 2026 8:57 am

I was 68 when had my implant done. There are a few who have had an implant done at older ages.
With pills or injections sex was always a scheduled thing which kills the mood. Hated that part.
Fought ED for 13 years and I'm sure it affected my length. Lack of erections allows tissues to shrink. My opinion is do the implant asap so you don't lose size.
Nov. 8, 2019
6+ years, Coloplast Titan OTR
Married 38 years to my beautiful young bride
Always here to answer questions if you PM me

User avatar
GoodWood
Posts: 1504
Joined: Sun Jun 16, 2019 1:07 pm

Re: To implant or not. Opinions needed

Postby GoodWood » Tue Jan 27, 2026 10:28 am

Gumby1 wrote:…I’m afraid I may reach a point when it may stop working

…I’m now approaching say 65-70, is that going to impact my ability to even get the surgery ?

The other issue I have is the lack of spontaneity, …

Then there’s traveling for vacation…TSA which would be hard to explain.


I can definitely relate to the dilemma. I used injections for over 10 years and had my implant surgery in March.

You might eventually reach a point where injections stop working—but you might not. Some men never do. In my case, the dose kept going up until the compounding pharmacy couldn’t make it any stronger. I was using a full 100 units (1 mL), taking 10 mg of daily Cialis, and wearing a cock ring. That combination gave me about 15–20 minutes of usable erection. It felt a bit like a starter pistol going off—I had to get the job done quickly. Not exactly sexy.

The important thing to remember is that you don’t have to wait until injections stop working. For now, they are working, so you’re not backed into a corner.

I also wouldn’t worry about your age or whether you’ll be approved for surgery. It’s a relatively minor procedure—though no surgery ever feels minor when you’re the one having it (LOL). If you’re healthy enough to have sex, you’re healthy enough for anesthesia. You’ll need cardiology clearance, but as long as you haven’t had a recent heart attack, stents placed within the last year, or a recent worsening of heart failure, you’ll almost certainly be cleared. That said, recovery is generally easier when we’re younger.

The lack of spontaneity with injections is absolutely a real consideration. What I love most about the implant is that I can pump up anytime—and I can have sex more than once every other day. I did everything I could to work around the limitations of injections, but the implant wins this round, hands down.

I traveled frequently during the 10+ years I used injections and never found it to be much of a hassle. A small travel case designed for diabetics using insulin worked perfectly. And don’t worry about TSA—they’re looking for weapons and contraband, not prescription meds. Tons of people travel with injectable medications. With the rise of GLP-1 drugs for weight loss, even more people are carrying injections now. I was never questioned by TSA—not once. And even if they did ask, “It’s my prescription medication” would be the end of the conversation. They don’t ask what it’s for, and they don’t care.

The bad news is that no one can give you a perfectly clear, one-size-fits-all answer about what you should do.

The good news is that you’ll have erections either way. Injections are working now, and an implant will work too. No matter which path you choose, you win.

I’ll leave you with one last thought. It’s very common for men with implants to say, “I wish I had gotten my implant sooner.” It’s extremely rare to hear someone say, “I wish I had waited longer.”

So if you’re thinking this might be the right time for you, it probably is.
57yo, NYC. ED started at 40. Pills, then shots for 10 years. 24cm Coloplast Titan XL w/classic pump by Dr Eid 3/25/2025. Will meet for show & tell.
Implant journal: [url] viewtopic.php?f=6&t=26225[/url]

User avatar
Kodixx
Posts: 879
Joined: Wed Jan 08, 2025 5:32 pm

Re: To implant or not. Opinions needed

Postby Kodixx » Tue Jan 27, 2026 12:58 pm

Gumby1, the question of whether this is the right time is a question only you can answer. However, you may find inspiration from the thread below :)

“I wish I’d done it ten years earlier…”
https://www.franktalk.org/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=6&t=27765&start=20&hilit=life+is+what+happens

- Chuck
Gumby1 wrote:The other issue I have is the lack of spontaneity, always having to say, “I’ll be right back” in the middle of foreplay. Then there’s traveling for vacation and having to pack the injections with ice which so far, I’m fortunate that I haven’t been questioned by TSA which would be hard to explain. Soooo… do I wait or do I pull the trigger pre-emptively ?
Feb 2025 58yo, 38 w/ greatest wife ever
AMS CX, Tenacio, Dr Broghammer (excellent) pre-op L:7", post-op @ 9 mo L: 6.5=>7.0" G: 5.5=>5.75"
2wks pain, cycling/sex @ 7wks, minor pain until 10wks, felt like 'new normal' sex @ 16wks

User avatar
ElbowRoom
Posts: 895
Joined: Mon Mar 17, 2025 1:58 pm

Re: To implant or not. Opinions needed

Postby ElbowRoom » Tue Jan 27, 2026 2:52 pm

Even though I used them for over a decade, I think injections should be considered a temporary solution. They can cause pain, fibrosis, decreased sensitivity, and Peyronie’s disease, as well as losing efficacy over time.

I lucked out and escaped most (but not all) or these issues, but if I had it to do over again, I would have only used injections long enough to arrange an implant surgery. YMMV.
58yo Coloplast Titan 28cm Penoscrotal with Dr. Hakky 10/21/2025.
Pre-op erect measurements:
8.5"L and 6.5"C

Post-op: 8”L and 6”C at one week.
8.5” and 6”C at three weeks with full glans engorgement


Return to “Implants”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: ClaudeBot, Facebook, Google [Bot], JohnnyBorg and 51 guests