Which surgery is best for me? Penoscrotal or infrapubic?

[Wooody]

With a good surgeon, either way will get good results. The reason people say go with what your surgeon recommends is because many surgeons prefer one method over the other, for various reasons. Dr Clavell told me he does PS because he feels he gets the best results and that's the method he uses. The Dr I chose, Dr Karpman, uses IP for the same reasons. Why ask them to use a method they're not comfortable with? If you're dead set on one method, then have that be one of the criteria for your choice of surgeon. I had it done IP and had great results, no noticeable tubing whatsoever, and a quick pain free recovery.

[ElbowRoom]

I think you made the right choice. IP is probably easier for the doc, but PS is more difficult, but less intrusive. The hard part for the doc is getting the reservoir placed. Now everyone will say I'm full of shit, but that's a given.

That was the hardest part of my surgery. Dr. Hakky said because I'm relatively slender and the space of Retzius is somewhat small on me, that the reservoir tried to keep popping upward and forming a visible bulge. After several attempts to get it to stay put he used a figure-8 suture stitch as would be used in a hernia surgery, to secure it in place. So far so good, it's very well hidden and seems to be working as designed.

[ElbowRoom]

I had this same question and decided that PS was best for me, even before I chose a surgeon.

The ONLY thing that I am going to interact with in terms of this implant is the pump, and I'm going to use it often. I wanted that pump placed exactly where it should be and not worry about tugging on it during healing or having it end up too high because it being more difficult to place going IP. I don't give a crap where the reservoir is, as long as I can't see or feel it, but I DO care where the pump is in my scrotum.

Just FYI I did PS surgery and my pump was quite high on the right side, and required pulling to bring it down.